|
|
|||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||
![]() |
|
||||||||
|
Breaking NFL News |
|
POSTED 10:04 p.m. EST; UPDATED 10:30 p.m. EST, February 8, 2006
RAVENS UNLIKELY TO LET KOKINIS GO
A league source tells us that the Baltimore Ravens most likely will not allow pro personnel director George Kokinis to join the New York Jets amid reports that new G.M. Mike Tannenbaum would like to hire Kokinis into the same position.
League rules permit teams to block front office personnel who are under contract from making lateral moves. The duration of Kokinis's contract is not known.
"Unless you are going to be a GM or head coach, the owners have made it impossible to get promotions unless you are granted permission by your club," said one league insider.
So Tannenbaum will be required to hire someone who currently is not employed, or a guy whose contract expires after the 2006 draft. Alternatively, he'll be required to promote from within and backfill by hiring entry-level scouts.
KUBIAK WANTED GIBBS
One of the more intriguing story lines to date in the 2006 offseason has been the status of former Broncos secondary coach David Gibbs.
Gibbs abruptly was fired by Broncos coach Mike Shanahan in November 2004. Shanahan never gave a reason for the move, and we'd heard that defensive coordinator Larry Coyer instigated the move because players were going to Gibbs more often than to Coyer with questions.
Recent developments suggest that, indeed, the move had nothing to do with Gibbs' abilities. Why? Because we're now told that Shanahan lieutenant Gary Kubiak offered Gibbs the job of defensive coordinator with the Houston Texans.
Gibbs declined the offer, opting instead to join the Kansas City Chiefs as defensive backs coach after spending a year as the defensive coordinator at Auburn.
"Her family lives in Lawrence," Gibbs recently said. "With a second child on the way, this was the perfect opportunity to get closer to her home."
If Gibbs plays his cards right, he might be in line to succeed current Chiefs defensive coordinator Gunther Cunningham.
Unless, of course, too many of the Kansas City defenders go to Gibbs with questions than to Cunningham.
FASSEL THINKS HE MIGHT GET RAIDERS GIG
There's talk in league circles that Ravens offensive coordinator Jim Fassel believes he's got a real shot at becoming the next head coach of the Oakland Raiders.
Some league insiders believe that Steelers offensive coordinator Ken Whisenhunt won't accept the Raiders job, if it's offered to him.
"He'd be one of the top candidates next season and could probably pick his job," said one league source.
With most of the offensive starters returning to the Steelers and another full offseason to work with quarterback Ben Roethlisberger, Whisenhunt's star will only rise in 2006 -- as will offensive line coach Russ Grimm's. Possible head coaching vacancies could arise a year from now in Baltimore, Tennessee, Jacksonville, San Diego, Dallas, Atlanta, Arizona, and Seattle.
MORE MOTOWN MADNESS
We regret to inform our readers that this will be our final update for a while.
Several weeks back, yours truly told a reader that if former Rams head coach Mike Martz lowered himself to accepting an offensive coordinator position in 2006, yours truly would eat his computer.
On Wednesday, Martz was named offensive coordinator of the Detroit Lions.
Martz reportedly was offered the job a week ago, then reportedly backed out because of money. Subsequent reports indicated that no offer was made, because new Lions coach Rod Marinelli simply wasn't sufficiently comfortable with Martz.
But then reports surfaced that the door might still be open, which made no sense in light of the story undoubtedly leaked by the Lions that they didn't want Martz.
Apart from the team's bizarre willingness to continue the courtship of Martz under these circumstances, Martz's addition to the franchise makes no sense. Marinelli claims that the Lions will be tough, disciplined, hard-nosed. Martz's brand of offensive football has never exhibited any of those traits.
Besides, if we were Matt Millen, we'd keep our eyes on Martz, especially when he gets within earshot of anyone named Ford. It doesn't take a genius to realize that Martz craves power -- and that Millen has a tenuous hold on it.
Then again, Martz could save Millen's cookies if Martz can do with the team's offense something that the team's two prior head coaches, both of whom had offensive backgrounds, couldn't accomplish -- move the ball and score points on a consistent basis.
Martz also will serve as the team's quarterbacks coach, and his first job unlikely will be to make a recommendation as to whether Joey Harrington should be brought back for another season. The other quarterback under contract for 2006 is Dan Orlovsky.
POSTED 10:41 a.m. EST, February 8, 2006
INTRODUCING . . . THE KORNCRUISER?
The worst-kept secret in broadcast circles is finally out of the bag. Al Michaels has bailed on his contract with ESPN, and the four-letter network for which, according to one of our industry sources, Michaels once said he'd never work will now turn to a three-man unit of Mike Tirico, Joe Theismann, and Tony Kornheiser.
But Kornheiser, like his MNF predecessor John Madden, is averse to flying. We're told that Kornheiser has said on his D.C.-area radio show that, like Madden, he'll take a bus from city to city.
Hello . . . Korncruiser?
Kornheiser will continue to handle ESPN's Pardon the Interruption with Michael Wilbon. On Mondays during football season, the show will air from the site of the NFL game.
The official ESPN.com story makes no mention of Michaels. He is expected to join Madden at NBC, where the duo will cover Sunday night football.
POSTED 10:08 a.m. EST, February 8, 2006
NFL SAYS JACKSON WAS OUT OF BOUNDS
At a time when plenty of calls from Super Bowl XL are getting plenty of criticism, the NFL has put to rest one of the disputed officiating decisions from Sunday night.
With less than a minute to play in the first half, Seahawks receiver Darrell Jackson caught a pass near the end zone, got one foot in bounds, and kicked the pylon with the other foot before the second foot landed out of bounds. The pass was ruled incomplete, and there was no booth review.
"We've looked at it carefully and it's the right call," NFL spokesman Greg Aiello told us Wednesday morning. "The key is that he had to get his second foot down in bounds. . . . He did not get his second foot down in bounds and therefore it is not a completion."
However, ESPN's John Clayton previously interpreted a 2002 rule change as making such a move a valid touchdown. On Tuesday, Peter King of Sports Illustrated and HBO offered a similar interpretation of the rule on WGR in Buffalo.
"John Clayton is wrong and [Peter] King now knows it's a good call," Aiello said.
So why the confusion? The official language is arguably ambiguous. Per Rule 3, section 20, article 1(b): "A player or an official is out of bounds when he touches anything other than a player, an official, or a pylon on or outside a boundary line."
So touching a pylon doesn't make the player out of bounds. But, as we explained on Tuesday, it also doesn't make him in bounds.
Of course, this doesn't mean that the Seahawks faithful will quit complaining about several other calls, but this is one on which they've got no plausible basis to gripe.
POSTED 9:23 a.m. EST, February 8, 2006
JETS TARGETING KOKINIS?
A league source tells us that the New York Jets likely will pursue Ravens director of pro personnel George Kokinis after the April draft.
Kokinis, we're told, is "very tight" with new Jets G.M. Mike Tannenbaum, and Kokinis also has a good relationship with new Jets coach Eric Mangini.
With that said, it's unlikely that Ravens G.M. Ozzie Newsome will allow Kokinis to leave for anything other than a G.M. gig. Per league rules, teams can block front-office moves that do not involve "final say."
As we explained last night, former Jets G.M. Terry Bradway likely will stay with the team through the completion of the April draft, since an earlier departure would enable him to take his months of personnel research to another franchise. Once Bradway goes, it will be incumbent on Tannenbaum to replace Bradway's personnel expertise.
TANNENBAUM'S CATCH-22
New Jets G.M. Mike Tannenbaum has a slight problem. On one hand, he needs to convince the media and the fans (and, most importantly, himself) that he has the requisite experience to be a General Manager. On the other hand, he needs to distance himself from the string of General Management embarrassments that have plagued the Jets over the past few years.
"Since 1997, I feel like I've been a G.M. in training," Tannenbaum said on Tuesday. "I've been involved in every conceivable transaction: Trading up in the draft, trading down in the draft, losing players in the restricted market, gaining players in the restricted market, most notably Curtis Martin in 1998."
"Involved" is the key word. Because if Tannenbaum was "involved" in, say, the decision to trade up to get so-so defensive tackle Dewayne Robertson at No. 4 in 2003, that's not a mark of, you know, competence.
Likewise, if he was "involved" in the decision to slap only a mid-level tender on receiver Laveranues Coles in 2003, it's not a good thing.
Or if he was "involved" in the decision to trade Santana Moss for Coles in 2005, it's not a good thing.
Or if he was "involved" in the the Chad Morton fiasco in 2003, it's not a good thing.
Here's a quick refresher. The 'Skins signed Morton, a restricted free agent, to an offer sheet. The Jets matched the Washington offer.
But the Jets didn't match all of the key terms, so an arbitrator decided that the Jets really didn't match the offer -- and declared that Morton was the property of the Redskins.
Wrote Vinny DiTrani of The Bergen Record at the time: "Unfortunately for the Jets, they heeded the legal advice from people supposed to provide legal advice."
And, at the time, the guy presumably providing that advice was assistant G.M., cap expert, and trained legal advice provider Mike Tannenbaum.
Then there's the recent handling of the departure of coach Herm Edwards and offensive coordinator Mike Heimerdinger, both of which events occurred at a time when Tannenbaum's influence presumably was at its highest point during his tenure with the team.
So Tannenbaum is caught in a trap. The only way that he has enough experience to run all aspects of a front office is if his fingerprints are sufficiently affixed to the string of bad decisions that fueled the departure of his former boss. And if that's the case, Tannenbaum should have gotten pushed out, too.
COWHER GETS IN BIG SHOW'S CRAW?
Although it's virtually impossible to sift through the chain of events that unfolded immediately after the final gun sounded in Super Bowl XL, it appears that Seahawks coach Mike Holmgren did not seek out Steelers coach Bill Cowher for the traditional post-game handshake.
Whether Holmgren intentionally dissed Cowher isn't specifically known. However, one of our sources who was on the field at the time tells us that Holmgren was clearly "pissed."
Another source tells us that Holmgren might have been upset with the fact that Cowher had his family on the field with him in the waning moments of the game. Though it doesn't seem like much of a big deal to us, it's apparently a major no-no among NFL types for family members to be anywhere in the vicinity of the playing area before the clock strikes zero.
BENGALS DELIVERED STEELERS WIN?
When we heard Steelers coach Bill Cowher re-ignite the "Who Dey? . . . We Dey!" chant at Tuesday's parade in Pittsburgh, it seemed a bit odd. After all, it's been four long weeks since the Steelers went into Cincinnati and vanquished the AFC North champion Bengals -- and the Steelers have had three much bigger wins since then.
But maybe Coach Chin's mild obsession with sticking it to the Bengals traces back to the Steelers' last loss, which came at home on December 4 against Cincinnati. After the game, several Bengals crowed that the balance of power had shifted in the division, and that the Bengals had assumed residence of the penthouse formerly occupied by Pittsburgh.
Our guess, based on Cowher's resort to the "Who Dey?" thing on Tuesday, is that the thing that ultimately got the team's fire going for the balance of the year wasn't some non-sequiting story about Christopher Columbus but the hatching of a burning desire to introduce the guys from Cincy to the new boss, who's the same as the old boss.
Moving forward, look for the Steelers to strengthen their grip. Sure, there will be free-agent losses in Pittsburgh. But there always are, and yet Cowher's crew continues to win more games than it loses.
The Bengals, meanwhile, are reeling. Franchise quarterback Carson Palmer isn't available until September at the earliest. Receiver Chris Henry might never be back. And receiver Chad Johnson's halftime behavior during the playoff loss to the Steelers has created an internal issue that won't go away if, by all appearances, coach Marvin Lewis continues to act like it was no big deal.
So just when it looked like the Bengals had finally beaten down the boys from the 'Burgh, the Steelers own the Lombardi -- and they likely will dominate the division in 2006 and beyond.
POSTED 9:41 p.m. EST, February 7, 2006
DISASTER LOOMING FOR JETS
Multiple league insiders believe in the wake of the decision of the Jets to elevate Mike Tannenbaum to General Manager that the two utes who'll now be running the show in New York will destroy the franchise.
The thinking is that, while both Tannenbaum, 36, and head coach Eric Mangini, 35, are talented, neither is ready for the job they now hold. As one league source told us, "[It's] just another case of a cap guy taking over a team. A guy who is not and never will be a football guy. There is no one in the Jet organization capable of making a good personnel decision. When will these owners learn that in order to win, football people have to make football decisions? I am not sticking up for Terry [Bradway], I am just speaking out against a cap guy who doesn't have a clue about football. They control the money and they think they know something about the game. Trust me, the Jets will be losers for years. The Giants must be happy because they will have no competition from the other New York team." And this train wreck couldn't be playing out in a worse city. On Tuesday afternoon, Tannenbaum came off as flustered and nervous while taking questions from WFAN's Mike Francesa and Chris Russo that, by New York media standards, were Styrofoam softballs dipped in powdered sugar. The root of the problem, as Francesa and Russo pointed out, is that Tannenbaum's stated commitment to getting the players that Mangini needs could be problematic, since Mangini doesn't quite know what he needs. And there will be a time when Mangini wants one guy and the scouts want another guy and Tannenbaum will be called upon to make a final decision. But he doesn't have the credentials or the experience to do it. In a few months, he won't have Bradway to turn to for advice. Although we heard earlier on Tuesday that Bradway had the option to leave after being demoted, one league source explained to us that there's no way the team would have let him bolt before the draft, given that he's already got months of research that he could have carried to a new team.
Likewise, several league insiders expect that, not long after the draft, Bradway will hit the highway.
So Bradway is essentially done, even though he'll finish out the next couple of months as a member of the organization.
The next question, then, is where Tannenbaum will turn for personnel expertise after Bradway goes. If Tannenbaum has the same kind of trouble that Mangini did when the time came to hire a staff, major problems are indeed brewing in Gotham.
In fact, Tannenbaum might have trouble keeping his scouts on board. If he's going to continue to suggest that he has figured out by osmosis how to evaluate personnel over the past five season, he'll lose any and all credibility that he ever had in the organization.
So based on what we're hearing, we expect a full and complete house cleaning in two or three years. Mangini and Tannenbaum will move on in the business, and they might ultimately be extremely successful. But the coming couple of seasons in New York could help to redefine the word "suck."
POSTED 1:33 p.m. EST; LAST UPDATED 1:46 p.m. EST, February 7. 2006
BRADWAY OUT AS JETS G.M.
A reader tells us that WFAN in New York reports that the Terry Bradway is out as the General Manager of the Jets. Mike Tannenbaum is the new G.M., and Bradway will stay on in a reduced role.
A league source tells us that Bradway will become the director of college and pro scouting. The source also says that Bradway had the option to take the demotion and stay, or to seek employment elsewhere. Some thought he might consider landing in Kansas City.
The Jets' web site is silent on this issue, but it announces that a "major press conference" will be conducted at 3:00 p.m. EST on Tuesday.
Several league insiders saw this one coming, but it's a surprise that it has happened so soon. Recently, we explained that Bradway's habit of working out of his home created an opening for Tannenbaum, who was walking the halls (and presumably working the owner) on a regular basis. It is widely regarded that Tannenbaum was instrumental in the decision to hire Eric Mangini, a close friend of Tannenbaum's, as the new head coach.
Indeed, the source tells us that the Bradway-for-Tannenbaum swap was agreed upon with owner Woody Johnson when Mangini was hired last month.
The only problem is that Tannenbaum is regarded as a cap guy, not as a football guy. Perhaps Bradway, then, will focus solely on the personnel aspects of the position, and Tannenbaum will do the rest.
Four years ago, Tannenbaum nearly left the team when former coach/G.M. Bill Parcells was poised to land in Tampa. After Parcells pulled out, Tannenbaum stayed put.
POSTED 11:30 a.m. EST, February 7, 2006
REFS GOT JACKSON CALL RIGHT
The saga continues regarding the question of whether Seahawks receiver Darrell Jackson's second-quarter touchdown that wasn't was the right call.
Several readers sent to us a link to a 2002 article from ESPN.com's John Clayton, in which the Professor proclaims, per a new rule, "a pass would be considered complete if one foot touches the pylon and the other foot is in bounds."
However, the official NFL.com story regarding the 2002 rules changes says nothing about the pylon being part of the field of play. Instead, the NFL.com version states merely that "[a] player no longer an be ruled out of bounds when he touches a pylon unless he already touched the boundary line."
The pylons are positioned on the boundary lines at the front and back of the end zone, and are thus out of bounds. The old rule was that touching the pylon was akin to touching the white line on which the pylon is perched, making the player necessarily out of bounds. Under the 2002 revision, a player may now touch the pylon without being instantly regarded as out of bounds.
Here's the key -- touching the pylon doesn't mean that the player is in bounds, either.
If Jackson had gotten one foot in bounds, kicked the pylon with the other foot, and then gotten that other foot in bounds, it would have been a touchdown. Merely touching the pylon with one foot is not enough, contrary to Clayton's story, to make the reception count.
So after further review of our further review, we'll say that the call was a correct one.
Hey, at least we're committed to getting it right. Even if it takes a few tries.
POSTED 7:08 a.m. EST; LAST UPDATED 8:40 a.m. EST, February 7, 2006
BIG SHOW SOUNDS OFF ON REFS
Although Seahawks coach Mike Holmgren had nothing to say about the questionable calls that marred Super Bowl XL on Sunday, the Big Show took a shot at the zebras during a rally for the team on Monday at Qwest Field.
Said Holmgren: "We knew it was gonna be tough going against the Pittsburgh Steelers. I didn't know we were gonna have to play the guys in the striped shirts as well."
The NFL prohibits coaches and team officials from criticizing officials. Several fines were imposed during the 2005 season on coaches. Steelers linebacker Joey Porter did not get slapped with a fine for accusing the refs of trying to help the Colts get to the Super Bowl, supposedly since the NFL holds coaches to a higher standard.
JACKSON TOUCHDOWN SHOULD HAVE COUNTED?
We explained in our Super Bowl XL X-Pack that the second-quarter goal line catch by Seahawks receiver Darrell Jackson should not have counted because, even though his left foot landed in bounds and his right foot struck the pylon, the pylon is clearly out of bounds.
On further review, we might have been wrong.
Among the crush of e-mails we have received following Super Bowl XL were a couple messages from readers containing a link to a story penned by ESPN's John Clayton in 2002 regarding new rules changes.
One of the adjustments passed was as follows: "A player will be ruled in bounds if he touches the pylon at the goal line before going out of bounds. For example, a pass would be considered complete if one foot touches the pylon and the other foot is in bounds."
In Jackson's case, one foot clearly was in bounds and the other foot clearly hit the pylon.
If that rule change has not since been dumped, then the failure of the officials to get the Jackson call correct was, in our opinion, the worst call of the game -- even though it has received, by far, the least attention.
We've looked at the tape (again), and Side Judge Tom Hill was standing right there watching Jackson's feet. Hill saw one foot land in bounds, and he saw the second foot hit the pylon.
And since the play occurred with less than two minutes remaining in the first half, the replay official didn't buzz referee Bill Leavy to take another look-see at the play -- even though the Steelers called a time out before the next play, giving the replay official even more time to get it right.
This is the call that, in our opinion, should get someone fired. It would have given the Seahawks a 9-7 lead, pending the extra point, with less than 50 seconds to play in the second quarter.
TUESDAY MORNING ONE-LINERS
Pittsburgh area students are expected to be in school on Tuesday, and not to skip out so that they can attend the Steelers parade (hey, kids -- carpe diem, which is Latin for "tell teacher to shove it up his or her ass").
Coach Chin came up with a speech based on Christopher Columbus to get his team to turn around a sinking season (meanwhile, half of them spent the rest of the year asking each other whether the guy used to play quarterback for Ohio State).
The last five Super Bowl losers prior to the Seahawks failed to make the playoffs the next season.
The Rams have rounded out their coaching staff.
We appreciate the fact that Barry Witz of The Los Angeles Daily News gave us a mention for the photo of the zebra in black-and-gold stripes, but we're hoping that someone will pick up on our far more serious suggestion that the NFL should incorporate modern technology into the process for officiating games.
Former Broncos CB Willie Middlebrooks has pleaded guilty to assault (he also should plead guilty to grand larceny for that first-round signing bonus he pocketed five years ago).
The Steelers would have gone for the touchdown on fourth-and-millimeters, if the call had been that Big Ben didn't score.
The Texans are still waiting to hear from former Packers coach Mike Sherman in response to an offer to join Gary Kubiak's staff.
The NFL reportedly was selling Terrible Towels at Ford Field, but no similar cheering props for the Seahawks.
From Greg Cote of The Miami Herald: "Watching Aretha Franklin, Dr. John and Aaron Neville perform the national anthem, I couldn't help but marvel that in their lifetimes the three of them have combined to win more than 20 Grammys and apparently miss fewer than four meals."
This comment from Titans coach Jeff Fisher bolsters our belief that the NFL needs to come up with ways to help the refs get it right every time: "Because of the enormous amount of coverage the game is getting, the officiating is getting scrutinized now more so than it has in the past."
Good news for New Orleans residents -- NFL football is returning to the Superdome on September 24. (Bad news for New Orleans residents -- one of the teams playing will be the Saints.)
Joe Montana says that he didn't bail out on a Super Bowl appearance because of the money (instead, Montana was miffed that Steve Young would get to walk out of the tunnel before him).
POSTED 11:00 p.m. EST; UPDATED 11:30 p.m. EST, February 6, 2006
PFT X-PACK: SUPER BOWL XL
We no longer regard January 1 as the first day of the year. For us, New Year's Day is the morning after the Sunday in early February on which the passing of another 12 months is noted by the arrival of the football game with the Roman numeral.
So as we welcome year XLI S.B., we reflect on the X of the things from the final day of XL S.B. that caught our attention.
I. "Have Some Corn With Your Butter."
It's a favorite family quote spawned a few years ago when Florio Jr. was in the midst of slopping a half a stick of Land O' Lakes onto an ear of corn. And it's something that we now use whenever someone is allowing the thing that's supposed to be the add-on to overtake the thing that isn't.
This principle came to mind as we attempted to keep up with nine-and-a-half hours of Super Bowl pregame coverage.
Nine. And. A Half. Hours.
How ridiculous was it? Sister corporations ESPN and ABC were in direct competition with their respective pregame shows for a full 150 minutes.
Sometimes less is more, folks. Especially when we're all going to cap off the day by spending four hours watching, you know, the game itself.
II. Oh Say Can You Shut Up?
This time around, the National Anthem was as bad as we can recall it being at any event we've ever seen. The singing sounded like a couple of American Idol auditions that would make Simon scowl and say something akin to "It sounded like Mean Joe Greene clamped his teeth onto your scrotum." Fortunately, our own sense of hearing was somewhat distracted by that Folsom Prison-quality tattoo on the left cheek of Aaron Neville and the nagging question of how in the world the crack of Aretha Franklin's ass was peeking through the top of her shirt.
III. The Calls.
We've spilled plenty of e-ink regarding the brouhaha that has erupted regarding the officiating, but we've yet to share our views on the calls that were -- and weren't -- made.
So here's what we think regarding the most critical officiating decisions from the Super Bowl.
First, the offensive pass interference call on Seahawks receiver Darrell Jackson was borderline at best. Yes, Jackson pushed off. A little. At a minimum, the flag on Jackson should have been negated by an illegal contact flag on Steelers safety Chris Hope, who grabbed at Jackson's arm well beyond the five-yard chuck zone -- and who then put his hands on Jackson an instant before the Jackson extended his arms.
Second, one of Jerramy Stevens' dropped passes actually was a catch and a fumble at the Steelers 25. But the officials blew the play dead as an incompletion before the Steelers could make the recovery, wiping out any chance at a replay review. Still, James Farrior would have recovered the ball inside the ten, and he might not have gotten back to the 20 via the return. On the very next play, Seahawks punter Tom Rouen kicked into the end zone, giving the Steelers the ball at the 20. So even though the call went Seattle's way, there was no real advantage.
Third, the Ben Roethlisberger touchdown was a questionable call on the field followed by a proper use of instant replay. The official who ran in from the sideline initially put his hand in the air as if he were going to spot the ball inside the one, and then the official abruptly decided that Roethlisberger had gotten into the end zone.
But what the hell did the guy see? Apparently, he was influenced by the fact that Ben pushed the ball into the end zone after the play ended. Since the replay angle was shot from the same perspective that the official had, it's hard to believe the official saw the ball break the plane.
On review, Bill Leavy made the right decision, since there was no indisputable evidence that the ball didn't get in. In fact, it looked to us as if the ball kissed the plane, which would make it a legitimate touchdown. But if the call on the field had been that Roethlisberger didn't get in, there wouldn't have been enough evidence via replay to reverse.
Bottom line -- it's time to develop an electronic system for determining whether the ball entered the end zone. Otherwise, the NFL should revert to the original rule requiring the runner to actually "touch down" the ball in the goal area.
Fourth, cornerback Kelly Herndon's long interception return included a block in the back on Roethlisberger, which would have put the ball at the Pittsburgh 48 instead of at the Pittsburgh 20.
Fifth, the holding call on Seattle tackle Sean Locklear that took the ball from first and goal at the two to second and 20 was weak, especially since the hold had no real impact on the play. If that flag isn't thrown, the 'Hawks would have erased the biggest deficit in Super Bowl history and claimed the lead in the fourth quarter.
Sixth, there was a horse collar tackle on Seahawks running back Shaun Alexander by Steelers linebacker Joey Porter on the same drive. But no flag from the officials.
Seventh, the fifteen-yarder called on Seahawks quarterback Matt Hasselbeck following his interception was one of the worst calls we've ever seen, and it put the Steelers closer to position for the razzle-dazzle pass from Antwaan Randle El to Hines Ward that iced the game.
So, as we see it, there were seven questionable calls, the bulk of which favored the Steelers.
One last thing. Several readers have argued that the long catch Seahawks receiver Darrell Jackson made at the goal line near the end of the first half should have been called a touchdown, since Jackson got one foot down and kicked the pylon with the other one. But the pylon is out of bounds. Although touching the pylon with the ball is enough to register a touchdown since the goal line extends beyond the field of play, the pylon is not actually in the field of play. So it was, after all, a good call.
Hey, at least they got one right.
IV. The Commercials.
Nothing remarkable this year. Burger King pissed away $5 million in air time early for a disturbing hamburger orgy. Otherwise, it was sort of blah.
And, as usual, the best and funniest spots arose from efforts of the folks at Anheuser-Busch to indoctrinate the next generation of beer drinkers.
Between drinking booze and playing Sudoku, it's a wonder we accomplish anything as a society.
V. Best . . . Promo . . . Ever.
The most compelling ad shown during the Super Bowl was the teaser for ABC's own Grey's Anatomy, which followed the game in most markets. Though we've only watched the show a handful of times, we stayed up to see the episode, which didn't get rolling on WTAE in Pittsburgh until well after midnight.
We won't blow the whole "Code Black" thing, in the event that some of you haven't watched it yet. But we'll say this -- the promo was a helluvalot more compelling than the show itself.
The show wasn't bad. But the teaser made our skin crawl.
VI. Kickers Were The Real Goats.
Lost in the pissing and the moaning regarding the officiating is the fact that Seahawks punter Tom Rouen hurt his team's ability to take advantage of a piss-poor performance by the Pittsburgh offense through three first-half punts into the end zone. At a time when the Steelers' offense was moving worse than the bowels of a cheese addict, the 'Hawks could have gone a long way toward taking charge of the scoreboard if Rouen hadn't ruined things by continuing to drop the pig onto the paint.
Meanwhile, Seattle kicker Josh Brown cost his team six points by missing two long-but-makeable kicks. It would have made the last few minutes of the game a lot more interesting if the Seahawks had been trailing by only five points.
VII. Randle El Was The Real MVP.
No disrespect to Hines Ward, but he shouldn't have gotten the free Escalade on Sunday. We would have instead given the Pete Rozelle Trophy and the ride with the big wheels and the blingy headlights to Antwaan Randle El.
Sure, Ward had the stats. Five catches for 123 yards and a touchdown, and an end around for 18. But he dropped a sure six-pointer, which MVPs just don't do. (Al Michaels and John Madden suggested that Ward wouldn't have been able to get both feet down on the play, but the replay suggested otherwise.)
Randle El didn't have the numbers, accounting for only 98 total yards. But he delivered three key plays for the Steelers. He converted the team's first first down of the game via a juggling run-and-catch. He threw the game-deciding touchdown pass. And he turned a shovel pass into a critical first down late in the game, as the Steelers were trying to kill the clock.
Also, Randle El missed only two plays after suffering what looked initially to be a serious injury after returning a second-quarter punt.
And the impact of the MVP award goes much farther beyond a new SUV and a fresh piece of hardware for the mantle. Randle El will be a free agent in less than four weeks. The resulting Vince Young effect would have delivered for Randle El the same kind of above-market deal that past Super Bowl MVPs received during the salary cap era, including Larry Brown, Desmond Howard, and Dexter Jackson.
For Ward, the MVP award just might have secured a spot for him in Canton, even if the Steelers don't win another Lombardi during his career.
On that topic, we think that the 2005 Steelers ultimately could place as many as six guys in the Hall of Fame -- Ward, coach Bill Cowher, running back Jerome Bettis, guard Alan Faneca, safety Troy Polamalu, and quarterback Ben Roethlisberger.
VIII. Where's Taz?
Although safety Troy Polamalu remains one of the most dominant defensive players in the NFL, he was MIA during Super Bowl XL. Maybe it was because of his ankle, which was injured on Wednesday and caused him to miss Thursday's practice. Or maybe the Seahawks came up with a way to neutralize him. Regardless, it was an uncharacteristically average performance for a guy who has a very bright future in the league.
IX. Brady Should Have Bowed Out.
We were troubled when we heard that Pats quarterback Tom Brady would be flipping the coin for the Super Bowl. The ultimate competitor, Brady shouldn't want to be at the game unless his team is playing in it. Instead, he was the center of attention just before kickoff.
Then it occurred to us that Brady likely believes that his team is better than either of the Super Bowl participants, and that he believes the Patriots would have beaten the Steelers or the Seahawks if their paths had crossed in the Super Bowl. So why not, as Brady possibly concluded, show up for the game and remind them all that the truly best team in the NFL wasn't in attendance?
Of course, the Pats could have had a crack at the Steelers in the wild-card round, if they hadn't laid down (as some believe they did) in the regular-season finale at home to the Dolphins. The thinking is that New England gladly took a loss during Week Seventeen in order to host the Jags as the four seed, instead of the Steelers as the three seed.
But for the Denver Broncos, the Pats' plan (if that indeed was the plan) would have been successful, with the Steelers forced to go to Foxborough for the AFC title game after upsetting the Colts.
Still, the Patriots didn't qualify for the game, and we think that Brady should have passed on the chance to take a piece of the spotlight from the teams that made it there.
X. Stone Deaf.
We've never been big fans of the Rolling Stones. We like some of their stuff, which is often brilliant in its simplicity.
But . . . it's . . . over. Men in their 60s don't prance and cavort and sing songs about women making dead men, um, excited -- especially when each of them is so close to becoming one of the very dead men to whom they refer.
We'll give them credit, however. The quality of their live performances hasn't eroded over time -- primarily because it was never very good to begin with.
As to the debate regarding whether the offending word from Start Me Up was bleeped by ABC or by the production itself, it sure sounded like a self-censor job, since the music could still be heard plainly at the instant that the term (which has made it way through years and years of radio play without incident) was blocked. Pressing the kill button usually results in a pulse of total silence.
And how about the black dude playing bass? If they'd placed him any farther from the rest of the band, he would have been plucking the four-stringer from inside the Seahawks' locker room.
Overall, the intermission show was very poor in comparison to last year's performance by Paul McCartney. And it makes us wonder what the NFL will do in 2007. All of the acts that appeal to multiple generations have played the gig. And with the league firmly committed to avoiding the wardrobe malfunctions and/or general impudence of more modern acts, there's a shrinking pool of pop/rock artists who are still out there.
FASSEL PLAN B FOR RAIDERS?
A league source tells us there's a rumor making the rounds that the Raiders will hire Ravens offensive coordinator Jim Fassel, if Steelers offensive coordinator Ken Whisenhunt doesn't become the new head coach in Oakland.
Whisenhunt, we're told, made the trip to Oakland on Monday to interview. Five others, including most recently former Raiders head coach Art Shell, have sat for the job.
At one point, we believed that the Raiders had a secret college coach in the mix, and that they were waiting for the February 1 letter-of-intent deadline to pass before announcing the hire. But it's been nearly a week since the new crop of recruits committed, and with each passing day the chances of a surprise NCAA arrival grows smaller and smaller.
POSTED 11:50 a.m. EST; UPDATED 12:47 p.m. EST, February 6, 2006
NFL AT A CROSSROADS
As the e-mails continue to click in at an unprecedented pace, with 90 percent of the readers complaining about the officiating from Super Bowl XL (and many suggesting that the fix was in), we've come to a final conclusion.
The NFL, as we see it, has a problem. A big one. A bigger one, in the bigger picture, than the looming CBA crisis.
Specifically, the NFL has a perception problem. And perception, as they say, is the awareness of the elements of the environment through physical sensation.
Oh, wait -- that's the textbook definition of the term. The rest of the world says that perception is reality.
And the perception is that the NFL is not fully committed to ensuring that accurate calls are made. A growing minority perceive that the NFL is actually dictating the outcome of games through officiating.
The reality, in our opinion, is that the NFL doesn't fix games. But there are just enough circumstances in which human nature has influenced key calls that have influenced the outcome of just enough key games to justify a belief among folks who usually don't buy in to conspiracy theories that a conspiracy is somehow at work.
So what to do? Our suggestion is that the NFL should take immediate steps aimed at a gradual but comprehensive overhaul of the manner in which games are officiated. The easy answer that many have offered is a requirement that the zebras be full-time employees of the NFL. But we believe that such an approach would cause more problems than it would solve, since plenty of the very bright men who sign on to be officials would be disinclined to give up their far more lucrative primary careers. As a result, the full-time officials would generally be cut from a lesser cloth.
The better answer, in our view, is for the NFL to fully embrace the advancements of technology. Here we are in the year 2006, and still the only things other than the naked eye on which the NFL relies in officiating games are: (1) two orange sticks separated by ten yards of metal chain; (2) a ticking clock; and (3) periodic reference to video footage that is otherwise instantly available to the millions of persons who watch the games on television.
When it comes to the use of technology in order to generate revenue, the NFL is roughly on par with Bill Gates and Steve Jobs. But when it comes to the use of technology in order to regulate its on-field product, the NFL is the equivalent of the grandma and pap-pap who let the microwave oven sit on the counter for six years before conjuring the nerve to plug it into the wall.
So it's high time, in our opinion, for the NFL to think creatively about ways that it can help its officials do a better job. We've previously argued that the NFL should install a computerized system into the end-zone pylons that would determine whether the ball touches the plane. If such a system were in place, one of the most hotly-debated calls from Super Bowl XL (i.e., whether Big Ben got the tip of the ball onto the front of the goal line) would have been a no-brainer. Per the computer system, the ball either went in, or it didn't. Sure, some people would still bitch about the outcome, but it would be another level of protection over and above the frailties of one man making a snap decision and the inherent imperfection of camera angles.
Although there were no controversial calls regarding whether a team made a first down during the Super Bowl, we've previously written about a laser-based system that permits the entire thing to be controlled and determined without the sound of the men . . . working on the chain . . . gang.
Think about that one for a second. We're doing James Bond sh-t with home electronics and the question of whether a professional football team covers ten yards of turf in four plays or less is still determined by two dudes who supposedly are holding big ugly poles in perfect position.
Here's the biggest innovation we're proposing. Video replay should become an integral tool for the determination of whether the officials got it right. And not just for the stuff that currently is reviewable -- for everything.
The key here is to come up with a quick and reliable way of permitting the replays to be checked. But the answer is easy. The NFL should install at each stadium a secure wireless network that would allow key shots to be immediately fed via a replay official working in the network trailer to a screen that is either strapped to the referee's wrist or palm.
And the referee should have the ability, upon review of the images between plays, to change anything.
For example, on that very questionable offensive pass interference call that wiped out a first-quarter touchdown reception by Seahawks receiver Darrell Jackson, Bill Leavy could have promptly looked at the replay on his Dick Tracy wristwatch and concluded that there were offsetting penalties on the play, since there was illegal contact with Jackson as he was entering the end zone.
Or Leavy could have decided that, although Jackson's arms were extended, there was no actual push.
Some will argue that such an approach will rob the officiating process of its human element. But, as the NFL gets bigger and bigger, that's precisely what needs to happen. The league must acknowledge that the officials are human, and the league needs to come up with ways to account for it.
Indeed, there's a theory making the rounds in league circles that the officials possibly still hold a grudge against Seattle coach Mike Holmgren for exposing the fact that the league secretly had apologized to him for some bad calls during a regular-season game against the Giants. Though, again, we doubt that Mike Pereira circulated a memo telling the zebras to mule kick the Big Show right in the Little Show, human beings are influenced from time to time by subconscious motivations. (If you don't believe it, just ask any Raiders fan.)
As to the notion that such a procedure will make the games longer, we disagree. First, not every play is going to require a review. Second, many of the plays can be reviewed as the offense is preparing for the next play. Third, if the ref needs to blow the whistle four or five times per game in order to double-check the video, so be it. It's far better for the game to go an extra ten minutes with complete integrity than it is to wrap the thing up and having folks bitching for the next five days about yet another display of incompetence.
So we send out a call today to everyone in and around the NFL to embrace the notion of dramatically upgrading the officiating process. And if anyone can come up with an argument against looking actively for ways to help out a bunch of middle-aged men trying to fix their middle-aged eyes on a bunch of kids whose body parts move in a cluster of blurs, we'd love to hear it.
We raise these points not to cause trouble, but because we believe that the NFL is the greatest diversion available to us all, and that the NFL has to be willing to protect its standing not through clever P.R. ploys aimed at convincing us that there really isn't a problem, but through acquiring an unwavering obsession to using whatever means necessary to get every call in every game right.
The perception, and the reality, are that the NFL currently does not demonstrate such dedication.
Which is feeding the perception that the NFL is, at its core, no different than the WWF.
MONTANA, BRADSHAW STIFFED BOWL OVER MONEY
49ers quarterback Joe Montana and Steelers quarterback Terry Bradshaw reportedly skipped out on the parade of Super Bowl MVPs prior to Super Bowl XL regarding the money, or lack thereof, that was available for the appearance.
The guys who appeared received $1,000 for incidentals, along with plane fare, a rental car, and game tickets.
Montana reportedly wanted $100,000. Bradshaw denies that his absence was due to money.
We're inclined to believe Bradshaw, since he had every reason to show up for, the game. The adoring crowd would have pumped more air into his oversized noggin, and he indirectly would have been helping to promote his role in the upcoming film Failure to Launch. In fact, we recall seeing Bradshaw on the set of the NFL Network at some point during the past week of oblongata-numbing Super Bowl coverage, so we doubt that he didn't want to be there.
As a result, we think that Bradshaw had some reason unrelated to the money that was, or wasn't, available. Maybe his contract with FOX prohibits appearances on other networks without approval -- and maybe the folks at FOX slapped him in the other bald head for his pop-in on the NFL Network last week. At a time when he's in line to become the new host of FOX NFL Sunday, the last thing Bradshaw needs to be doing is pissing off the powers-that-be.
As to Montana, what the hell was he thinking? Though he never played for the Steelers, the throng of Pittsburgh fans in attendance would have loved to heap praise on the local product from Ringgold High.
It cheapened the event, frankly, to have Montana and Bradshaw absent from one of the most compelling moments of the evening. And we're hoping that whoever was responsible for their absence gets plenty of flak for this one.
POSTED 12:18 a.m. EST; UPDATED 12:39 a.m. EST, February 6, 2006
'HAWKS HAVE RIGHT TO CRY FOUL
We'll need to preface these remarks by saying that we're glad the Steelers won the Super Bowl. The Steelers are a first-class organization in a first-rate town. Yours truly grew up an hour from the 'Burgh, went to college there, and started out in the practice of law there.
And the Steelers earned this one, the hard way. Sixth seed, winning three games against quality teams on the road to get to the championship game.
With all that said, the Seattle Seahawks have every right to believe that they got screwed by the zebras. We're into our fifth year now, and this game provoked the biggest flood of e-mails we've ever received.
So as we raise a lukewarm plastic cup of Iron City to the Stillers, we have to agree that the game was poorly officiated, in various ways. Although we're reluctant to proclaim that the fix was in, Pittsburgh linebacker Joey Porter's pissing-and-moaning from three weeks ago is ironic, to say the least, following a Super Bowl in which any of the 53 men in the Seattle locker room would be able to make the same claim about the refs wanting Jerome Bettis and the Steelers to win that Porter made regarding his belief that the officials hoped to deliver Peyton Manning and the Colts to Detroit.
Here's a sampling of the e-mails that flooded our box: 1. "I am not a Steelers or Seahawks fan, but I have to say that this was one of the worst officiated Super Bowls I've seen in a long time. Sad to see the refs have an impact on what would have been a great game." 2. "Okay, I'm on the
bandwagon now. That appeared to be one of the worst 3. "This Super Bowl sucks. As fans, we want to see a real game. The refs are CLEARLY handing this game to the Steelers. Your scoop on Sports Illustrated already having the Steelers retrospective printed up just seals it for me. I don't know if SI is part of a conspiracy, or if they just know how the NFL operates. A Steelers win equals more revenue for the NFL, in terms of merchandise. Holmgren should've taken that into consideration when he was offered the Seattle job."
4. "The NFL should be embarrassed. And I am an impartial fan. I didn't care who won but I sure didn't want to see it happen that way."
5. "Please for the love of GOD write something about the horrible officiating in the game today. Granted I'm a little biased and wanted the 'Hawks to win but if they lost I'd been fine if the Steelers were the better team. THEY WEREN'T and we played against the officials all night. Please say something about this injustice!"
Here's one we found to be particularly compelling: --------------------------------------------- I don't know who else I can vent on, so you're getting it. I apologize, but I don't know who else. I seriously don't. So here goes: This Super Bowl was it. I'm done now. I'm through watching football. I've had it. This was the worst officiated professional game I have ever watched -- the most one-sided, I mean. And it happened on the biggest game of the year. The two teams did not determine the winner of that game today; the referees did. So I'm through. I quit on the NFL. Screw them. If that's the best they can do, I quit. I've got other hobbies I can pursue. Look, I am not a Seahawks fan. I was not a fan of either team. But sonuvabitch-------Roethlisberger's PHANTOM TOUCHDOWN???? That was the hugest phantom touchdown I have seen since Vinny Testaverde pulled one of those off. And when Hasselbeck connected with TE Jerramy Stevens to the one yard line late in the third quarter, those asshole zebras throw a holding flag -- and it was one of those borderline holding calls that could literally BE CALLED ON ALMOST EVERY DAMN PASSING PLAY. Look, I came to watch a game, a game between football players. I didn't come to watch a crew of striped-shirted old men determine the outcome of a game. F those guys. I'm out. The hell with football. I no longer trust it. There was no 2005 champion. If the Steelers had won it, I'd say so. But the zebras won it, for 60 consecutive minutes. Again, I am not a Seahawks fan. I just care about the integrity of the game. I feel sick. I'm out. Maybe for good. The hell with it. --------------------------------------------- Damn. Here's some more. 6. "I'm a long time reader and supporter
of your site and I would love to 7. "Where's that big time wrestling channel. Joey Porter better shut his yap about the officials cheating the Steelers. They cheated their way to a World Title tonight." 8. "How about that officiating in the Super Bowl? Worst Super Bowl I've ever seen. Why did the NFL decide Pittsburgh would get this one? The third and six delay of game. Those holding calls (especially the one nullifying Stevens' catch to the one). The personal foul for illegal chop block on Hasselbeck MAKING A TACKLE. The offensive PI against Jackson. I am sick to my stomach right now, and I didn't even care who won. (Not a fan of either team, no money riding)." 9. "No one could have beaten the Steelers tonight, and it's not because they are playing especially well. Seattle is playing against 11 Steelers and however many officials are on the field. This is embarrassing to watch, and Pittsburgh should be embarrassed to win like this. Every pivotal play was negated against Seattle with some bullsh-t call, which would then be followed by a breakdown by Seattle players who obviously were shaken up by such a bullsh-t call. That touchdown that Roethlisberger had makes me wonder why we have replays as much or more so than the Polamalu call that you called the worst call ever. If the NFL is going to run its officiating with such bias like the NBA or MLB, then they might as well drop the salary cap too. Why do people go to games in cities like Seattle or Sacramento when they only get repeatedly f--ked in the ass by their respective leagues?" 10. "The REAL MVP was the referee crew.
They took the game from Seattle and gave it to the Steelers.
Don't get me wrong, I was pulling for Pittsburgh but I didn't
want to see them win like that. The Seahawks were the more
dominant team (although, not by much). Kinda seems weird to me
that 11. "You were one of the few national writers to pick the Seahawks to win the Super Bowl, and they were obviously the better team tonight. You mentioned 'raw will of players' and 'coaching adjustments,' but you forgot one major factor in the NFL . . . the zebras." 12. "Want to break a huge story? Why don't you use your connections and see who organized the Steelers Super Bowl fix? That would be the biggest story ever." 13. "Can you please, please acknowledge the horsesh-t calls in this game? This is the worst SB I have ever seen when it comes to officiating. Where are the calls on the Steelers?? This deserves to be mentioned and I am a Dolphins fan." Here's another long one that caught our eye: --------------------------------------------- I don't give a flying f--k about the Steelers or
the Seahawks. Furthermore, I ---------------------------------------------
Again, we don't think the fix was in. But there were more than a few times when the Steelers fans with whom yours truly watched the game looked around and said, "We got away with one there."
More to come in our Super Bowl XL Ten-Pack, which we'll post later on Monday.
BONNIE SWINGS HER VELVET HAMMER
Former CBS sideline reporter Bonnie Bernstein lashes out in her online diary regarding published reports as to her departure from the network that represent, in her words, "shoddy journalism." Writes Ms. Bernstein:
Larry Stewart reported that Bernstein's contract was not renewed by CBS. Surely, however, he didn't pull out of his poop-shoot the notion that CBS initiated the split. So our guess -- and it's just a guess at this point -- is that there's more to this one than meets the eye.
POSTED 2:43 p.m. EST, February 5, 2006
SUPER SEAHAWKS?
The Pittsburgh Steelers spent 42 years in the NFL before getting their mitts on a championship trophy.
The Seahawks are getting their first chance 30 years after they joined the club.
And although it pains us to say it (due that whole East Coast bias thing), the 'Hawks are going to get it done today.
There's no matchup in this one where one team has a clear edge over the other. So this game will come down to intangibles.
The Steelers roared through the AFC playoff field fueled on the perception of disrespect. The us-against-the-world mentality was so strong in three road wins that coach Bill Cowher opted for the team to wear white shirts in the big game, even though the Steelers technically are the home team. (It's actually the first time the AFL/AFC team ever has chosen to wear white as the home team in the history of the Super Bowl.)
But white shirts won't be enough to conjure up that same "no one believes in us" mojo. The Steelers are the favorites. Their fans have invaded Detroit by the thousand. The crowd, for the first time in the postseason, will primarily be rooting for them.
Cowher's crutch, then, just won't be there today -- putting even more pressure on him to come up big on the biggest of stages.
For the Seahawks, folks were already declaring that the Steelers would win the Super Bowl before the NFC title game had even started. But after watching the 'Hawks dismantle the Panthers, only a dude drunk on East Coast Kool Aid would regard a Pittsburgh win as a no-brainer.
It will be a tough, close contest decided by the quality of the in-game adjustments by the coaching staffs,and the raw will of the players involved to win.
The edge, on both counts, goes to Seattle, in our view. We're not saying the Steelers won't have the desire to win. We just have a feeling that the Seahawks will have more of it.
And we think the Big Show is far less likely to make a mistake. We still remember standing in the ice and snow a year ago in Pittsburgh watching Cowher outcoach himself while trying to outcoach Bill Belichick. We think it will happen again today, in one way or another.
There's too much pressure on the Steelers. Too much is expected. The last chapter of Bussie's fairy tale career needs to be written.
The Seahawks, on the other hand, have nothing to lose, since everyone expects them to. Look for the Big Show to whip his team into a lather, and for the Steelers to leave the Seahawks in the game long enough to steal it.
We hope we're wrong, but it's looking like Seahawks, 30-27.
POSTED 10:11 a.m. EST; UPDATED 10:29 a.m. EST, February 5, 2006
SI PRESUMING STEELERS WIN?
An astute reader who saw an offer on television for a Sports Illustrated package honoring the National Champion Texas Longhorns did a little digging and found out that the guys at SI are preparing a similar package for the ultimate winner of Super Bowl XL.
Since the Texas thing can be purchased via sitexasoffer.com, the reader punched in both sipittsburghoffer.com and siseattleoffer.com.
Both addresses link to an offer for a Super Bowl champion package. However, both links declare that the champions are the Pittsburgh Steelers.
Hey, Seahawks . . . . you gonna take that crap?
TOO-STRANGE-TO-BE-PHONY RUMOR COMES OUR WAY
A week ago, we scoffed at a tip from a reader that Bengals receiver Chris Henry was arrested in Florida for aggravated assault with a firearm while wearing his football jersey. So we didn't do anything with it.
Until, of course, it was reported by someone else that Henry had been arrested in Florida for aggravated assault with a firearm while wearing his football jersey.
This morning, we've received yet another facially incredible tip, and we're not going to completely ignore it while we otherwise try to track it down.
It involves a relationship, and pending a engagement, between two folks who make their living in and around the NFL. Though we're not 100 percent sure that disclosing the names based on the information we've received anonymously would create any potential legal liability, we're playing it safe for now.
But if it's true, and when it comes out, you'll be scooping your jaw out of your Froot Loops, just like we did.
More to come. Maybe.
POSTED 2:07 p.m. EST; UPDATED 2:14 p.m. EST, February 4, 2006
HALL GETS NEW CLASS
In voting results announced moments ago, the Pro Football Hall of Fame has added Troy Aikman, Harry Carson, John Madden, Warren Moon, Reggie White, and Rayfield Wright.
All six were finalists via voting that cut the pool from 15 to 10, and then to six.
Shut out for the second straight year was receiver Michael Irvin, who made the cut to the final ten.
The biggest travesty, in our view, is that Irvin lasted longer than receiver Art Monk, who has better overall stats than Irvin -- and just as many rings.
And so much for a bias against the Cowboys. Rayfield Wright? We're not saying that he's not worthy, but if there was such a bias, Wright never would have gotten in.
POSTED 12:06 p.m. EST; UPDATED 1:39 p.m. EST, February 4, 2006
OUR HOF CHOICES (IF ANYONE CARES)
Here's a shocker -- we don't have a Hall of Fame vote.
Here's another stunner -- we likely never will.
Still, the fact that no one asked for our opinion has ever stopped us from giving it.
Of the 13 regular finalists and two seniors committee candidates (Rayfield Wright and John Madden), we'd put in Cowboys quarterback Troy Aikman, Giants linebacker Harry Carson, Eagles/Packers defensive end Reggie White, and Redskins receiver Art Monk.
We'd think hard about Madden and quarterback Warren Moon and running back Thurman Thomas. In the end, however, we'd leave them on the shelf, at least for now.
As to Madden, we think he simply didn't coach long enough to earn a spot in the Hall.
As to Moon, all those regular season stats are nice, but he never got it done in January. He needs to stay on deck for five years or so.
Ditto for Thomas, who was one of the best in the league in his day, but was still a notch below Barry Sanders and Emmitt Smith. Thurman eventually gets in, but not yet.
Our guess is that the guys who'll get through this year are Aikman, White, Carson, Moon, and Madden. GET YOUR SUPER BOWL FIX AT PICK2PICK Super Bowl XL is upon us!! Steelers vs. Seahawks present an extra large contest! Our handicappers 3-Star consensus picks have hit over 70% this season. Make sure that you are on the right side of the line. Get your FREE expert Super Bowl picks plus daily NBA and NCAA Basketball picks at Pick2Pick.com. LIONS SNIFFING AROUND MARTZ AGAIN? According to The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, the Detroit Lions contacted former Rams head coach Mike Martz on Friday to determine whether Martz still might be interested in becoming the team's new offensive coordinator. This story comes a day after reports surfaced that a deal didn't get done because Lions head coach Rod Marinelli wasn't sufficiently comfortable with Martz, which reports came out a day after Martz said it was all about the money. Here's our take. Martz's camp leaked the story that the split came down to money. Then the Lions leaked the story that the team simply decided they didn't want Martz. And now Martz's camp is leaking the story that the Lions are still interested. Even if the truth is that it was Martz's decision not to consummate the transaction, the fact that the Lions painted the outcome as the result of a conclusion that Martz wasn't a good fit makes it virtually impossible for the Lions to change their position again. Or maybe not. These are the Lions, after all, who never seem to do anything right. So either Martz and/or his agent, Bob LaMonte are lying, or the Lions are even more screwed up than previously believed. Or, most likely, a little bit of both. SATURDAY ONE-LINERS Taz will play on Sunday despite an ankle injury.
[We still think Polamalu should return kicks on Sunday.] Donovan McNabb might be losing some of his juice in the Philly locker room. The Seahawks have an 11:00 p.m. curfew Saturday night (and, fortunately for them, they're miles and miles away from Pioneer Square). Fins co-defensive coordinator Will Mushchamp is leaving to become the defensive coordinator at Auburn following the arrival of Dom Capers to run the defense. Colts president Bill Polian says that WR Reggie Wayne either will sign a long-term deal, or he'll be slapped with the franchise tag. Colts QB Peyton Manning is mystified at the suggestion he called out his offensive line after the team's playoff loss (he apparently hasn't watched the tape), and he's hoping that RB Edgerrin James returns (here's a way to make it happen, Pey -- give up some of your 2006 salary). Chiefs WR Eddie Kennison is a little uncomfortable with the possibility that T.O. is coming to town (uh, oh -- maybe Kennison will quit the night before a game). Packers LB Nick Barnett could soon face criminal charges. We think that Michael Irvin has been using that pipe that was found under the driver's seat of his car if he truly believes that his November arrest actually helps his chances to get in to the Hall of Fame. POSTED 11:14 a.m. EST, February 4, 2006
TROY-TO-TEXANS RUMORS OFF BASE
We've received several e-mails this week from readers asking about message board rumors of a possible trade of Vikings receiver Troy Williamson to the Houston Texans, for running back Domanick Davis and one or more draft picks.
A league source with knowledge of Williamson's status tells us that such a deal has "no chance" of happening.
"It's the funniest thing both sides have heard in a while," said the source.
The fact that Williamson didn't have a major impact as a rookie likely is fueling trade speculation. But few first-year receivers have a Moss-esque impact, especially when the team on which the guy plays has a collection of seasoned veterans who are ready to contribute, such as Nate Burleson, Travis Taylor, Marcus Robinson, and Koren Robinson.
Williamson, in our view, will get at least two more years to show what he can do in Minnesota before the team would ever give serious consideration to moving him.
MEATHEAD COULD FACE TAMPERING CHARGES
Don Seeholzer of The St. Paul Pioneer Press reports that former Vikings coach Mike Tice could face tampering charges in the wake of blatant admissions that he has spoken to one of Minnesota's free agents about the possibility of joining Tice in Jacksonville.
Tice made the comment to a Jacksonville radio station on the same day that he was named the Jaguars' assistant head coach-offense.
NFL spokesman Greg Aiello told Seeholzer, "We're getting ready for the Super Bowl and will deal with other matters next week."
Vikings V.P. Rob Brzezinski declined to tell Seeholzer whether or not the team plans to file formal tampering charges.
In most cases, a formal charge is required before the league will take action. However, in most cases the evidence is usually vague and incomplete. Here, Tice stuck his own big foot in his meat-encrusted head, while a microphone was in his face.
Thus, when asked whether a complaint from the organization is necessary before the league would look into the matter, Aiello told Seeholzer, "Not really. They could actively make their views known to the league if they wish."
Tice's only possible defense would be that he made the contact with the player before officially signing up with the Jags. As one league source told us after we posted our own story regarded Tice's characteristically stoopid statement, contact would have been permissible before Tice became an employee of the Jaguars.
There's a gray area, then, as to when Tice actually became, for all intents and purposes, an agent of the Jags. Was it when he got an offer? When he verbally accepted? Or when he actually signed the deal?
A bright line is necessary, since a rule permitting a guy to round up former players after getting an offer but before formally accepting it could lead to all sorts of abuses.
Then again, there are already all sorts of abuses going on. To date, Tice has been the only one dumb enough to get caught with his meat hook in the cookie jar.
Kind of like when he got busted for scalping Super Bowl tickets, which went on long before Tice was caught -- and already is happening again.
POSTED 9:05 a.m. EST, February 4, 2006
TV TYPES HIT THE MERRY-GO-'ROUND
There's a sudden flurry of activity among the sock puppet set, with more TV types changing addresses than we previously can recall.
Then again, we never paid much attention to that aspect of the NFL until we became a quasi-watch dog regarding media stuff. As most football fans will say, it really doesn't matter who's covering the game. No one tunes in to marvel at the least common denominator stylings of a guy like John Madden. They just wanna watch the game.
Here are this year's changes of note.
With ESPN giving up Sunday night football and picking up the Monday night game, Mike Patrick and Paul Maguire are out, and Joe Theismann will work with Mike Tirico and Tony Kornheiser. (The Al Michaels exit from the contract he signed last year with ESPN isn't official, but it's now common knowledge that ESPN is letting Al pull a T.O.)
Also for the ESPN broadcast, Suzy Kolber stays on kissing-booth duty, and Michelle Tafoya takes the other side of the field.
On Sunday nights at NBC, Al Michaels and John Madden will reprise their Monday night roles, joined by Andrea Kremer, formerly of ESPN, who'll work the sidelines. (Though Kremer has improved tremendously over the years, we still have vivid recollections of her early days, featuring the constant Jennifer Wilbanks eyes.)
["I learned this look from the lady on the TV."]
At FOX, James Brown is leaving the pregame show to host the competition's effort at CBS. Likely replacing Brown at FOX will be Terry Bradshaw, who'll slide over one spot behind the desk. This opens up a seat at the FOX grown-up's table -- and we'll cast the first ballot now for anyone but Tony Siragusa to roll up a chair.
Brown's arrival at CBS bounces Greg Gumbel and the pet rat that sleeps on top of his head to the No. 2 broadcast team, with once-upon-a-time Monday night booth guy Dan Dierdorf. The move displaces Dick Enberg, who wasn't happy about it. Not one bit.
"I was shocked when I got the call," Enberg told The New York Times. "I still regard myself as being very strong on football, and I think we had a great season. I can't accept that my work is any less than it was in the past. I feel I story-tell as well as anyone. I won't take this as a defeat." (Yeah, but the rest of the world will.)
Elsewhere, it's been confirmed that Bonnie Bernstein is done as a sideline reporter at CBS. We'd heard that she wanted out. The Los Angeles Times says that her contract wasn't renewed, which implies that it was a network decision. Either way, we've got a feeling that Bernstein has pommel horsed the shark, and that she'll never been seen or heard from again in a national format. (Unless, of course, one of those news magazine shows does an item on her efforts to fleece up-and-coming broadcasters out of $1,250 for a phone consultation on how to get a job like the one she doesn't have anymore.)
Finally, CBS sideline reporter Armen Keteyian is graduating to CBS News. (Or is it a demotion?)
There still could be more adjustments, since the NFL Network still needs to put together a crew for the eight games that will be broadcast on the league-owned channel, beginning in November. Our pick would be Dick Enberg and John Riggins.
POSTED 10:21 p.m. EST, February 3, 2006
EMMITT STUMPS FOR IRVIN
Former Cowboys running back Emmitt Smith is angry with the possibility that teammate Michael Irvin's personal flaws might be blocking his entry into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
"This is what he's done off the field -- what has that got to do with what he's done on the football field?" Smith said Friday.
Irvin's playing career was marred by a plea of no contest to felony charges of cocaine possession. Efforts to rehabilitate his image (and earn a living sitting around talking about football) were marred a couple of months ago when he faced charges for possession of drug paraphernalia. Irvin was suspended for one week from his job with ESPN for failing to inform the network of the arrest. Irvin claimed that the marijuana pipe found under the driver's seat of his Mercedes belonged to a friend.
Smith believes that none of that should matter. "There should be a set criteria in terms of understanding and what it takes to get to the Pro Football Hall of Fame. If you're an athlete and you've got credentials like Michael Irvin -- Pro Bowls, records, Super Bowls, all those things -- if you stack up against that, whoever the panel is, somebody needs to sign off on it."
Fine. If Emmitt wants the vote to be based on numbers and numbers only, he's got it.
Irvin played in 159 games, and had 750 receptions for 11,904 yards and 65 touchdowns. He won three Super Bowls on teams that featured quarterback Troy Aikman and Smith, both sure-fire Hall of Famers.
Art Monk, another finalist for the Hall of Fame, played in 224 games. He caught 940 passes for 12,721 yards and 68 touchdowns. As a member of the Redskins, he won three Super Bowls with three different starting quarterbacks (none of whom will ever see the Hall of Fame without buying a ticket) and three different tailbacks.
So under Emmitt's criteria, Art Monk gets in before Irvin.
And, more importantly, if Monk gets in on his sixth try, it should take Irvin at least that many attempts to get in.
In other words, Emmitt and Troy and Michael and all of the other folks who claim that there is a Canton bias against the Cowboys should shut up about Irvin until 2010, at the earliest.
POSTED 2:36 p.m. EST; LAST UPDATED 3:37 p.m. EST, February 3, 2006
TAGS LOOKING FOR COVER?
NFL Commissioner Paul Tagliabue was somewhat pessimistic on Friday regarding the status of the negotiations on a new Collective Bargaining Agreement.
"We're not making the kind of progress we need to be making," Tagliabue said during his State of the League address. "I don't think negotiations are going very well.
"I do think there needs to be an outreach and more reality on both sides," Tagliabue said. "There needs to be a positive dose of reality on both sides of the table. To some degree, positions are hardening on both sides when they shouldn't be."
It's an odd statement, in our view, for the paid representative of NFL ownership to make. Indeed, Tags seems to be suggesting that his 32 bosses are being too hard headed.
Though we previously believed that Tags would pull the "all is well" thing when delivering his annual remarks on the condition of the greatest sports league in the known universe, it now looks like the Commish is trying to cover his caboose in the event that this thing eventually blows up.
Why? Because the 65-year-old Tagliabue is hitting the homestretch of his career, and if a work stoppage is inevitable he doesn't want the blame to fall on his lap.
We still think that a deal is coming. There's too much at stake not to work it out, for everyone involved.
Including us. I mean, what the hell would we write about? EDGE OUT IN INDY? Colts running back Edgerrin James think he has taken his last rep as the starting tailback of the defending AFC South champs. "I don't see nothing happening,'' James told The Indianapolis Star. "You can read between the lines and from the things I'm hearing, nothing's going to happen. "And that's crazy, man. I'm part of the solution, I'm not part of the problem. Crazy, man.'' James is scheduled to become an unrestricted free agent in March. A year ago, the team slapped the franchise tag on him after his rookie contract expired. He signed the $8.081 million, one-year tender not long thereafter, because (as we heard as the time) he was concerned that the team was ready to revoke it. Thereafter, there were rumors that the Colts would accept as little as a third-round draft pick in exchange for James' services. Per the CBA, using the franchise tag again on James would require a tender equal to 120 percent of his 2005 salary, which would be $9.7 million in real dollars and in 2006 cap room. If that kind of an offer hit the table, James undoubtedly would sign it in a heartbeat. Why? Because the free agent market for running backs, well, sucks. The guys drafted at the top of the first round last year (Ronnie Brown, Cedric Benson, Cadillac Williams) generally did better financially than the guys who already had proven that they can moves the chains at the pro level (Rudi Johnson, LaMont Jordan). The problem is that running backs absorb plenty of physical abuse. As they move past their 25th birthdays, the chances of ineffectiveness due to chronic injury increase. Then there's the constant threat of an ACL tear or some other devastating injury that leaves the guy potentially ineffective for years. That's why James and NFL MVP Shaun Alexander don't have long-term deals. Both guys have inflated perceptions of their worth. And both will need to spend some time on the open market in order to realize that, despite the glory they enjoy between the white lines, the really money simply is no longer there for the players who run the ball. "Maybe I'll get to a situation where somebody appreciates me,'' James said. But "appreciation" is irrelevant. The issue is how much a team can and will devote to the position of starting tailback under the salary cap, in light of the reality that there are plenty of guys hitting the draft every year who have the athletic ability to get the job done. Though the Colts need to keep in mind their won-loss record while James was out with a knee injury in 2001, the thinking apparently is that they can go young at the position via a first-day draft pick -- saving millions of dollars under the cap, which of course otherwise will end up in Peyton Manning's pockets. FRIDAY ONE-LINERS The Jags have signed C Dennis Norman to a four-year extension. We've confirmed that Chiefs G Brian Waters signed his recent contract extension, which had no signing bonus, without the assistance of an agent. From the "Too Many Elephants, Not Enough Guys With Shovels" file, Jags receiver Reggie Williams can avoid prosecution for marijuana possession resulting from a January 9 arrest simply by performing community service (his biggest service to the community would be to get the hell out of it). Pats DE Richard Seymour is optimistic that he'll work out a new contract with the team in 2006; last year, he briefly held out of training camp until the team "adjusted" his rookie deal. Seahawks RB Shaun Alexander, who will be a free agent in March absent a new deal, says that "[t]he Seahawks will make me a great offer right when the season is over and then I'll have a decision to make." (And the question Alexander asks should be framed as follows: "Is it worth an extra million or two over the life of the deal to get my kidneys lacerated due to a crappy offensive line?") Trial dates are set for the four Vikings accused of misdemeanors on Lake Minnetonka (we bet the bailiff can't wait to get his hands on the exhibits). Former Vikings WR Cris Carter thinks his old team needs to put its arms around QB Daunte Culpepper. Dick Jauron will use a Cover 2-style defense in Buffalo. POSTED 10:55 a.m. EST, February 3, 2006
MARTZ MOTOWN MELTDOWN NOT ABOUT MONEY?
Reports circulated on Thursday night that former Rams coach Mike Martz backed out of an opportunity to become the Lions new offensive coordinator because the Lions wouldn't increase their offer from $1 million per year to $1.5 million annually.
But now there are reports that Martz didn't land in Motown because new head coach Rod Marinelli wasn't sufficiently comfortable with him.
Even if that's true (and we're not sure it is), shame on the Lions for letting the jungle cat out of the bag regarding the possible arrival of Martz. Though we don't have the time or the inclination to figure out whether the initial reports of the potential hiring came from Lions sources or Martz sources, the point is that the Lions could have and should have ensured that all parties would be discreet as the two sides talked. Then, if the thing hadn't worked out, it wouldn't have been a big deal.
But now it is a big deal, and it strengthens the perception that the Lions organization is run by Festiva-driving slapdicks.
Still, we're not ready to exonerate Martz. Either he got an offer or he didn't. If he didn't get an offer and if he's lying now that he did, then every team should think long and hard about the possibility of ever hiring him in the future.
That doesn't mean the Lions are off the hook, even if Martz is failing to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. Martz was a bad idea from the outset, given the smash-mouth mentality that Marinelli is supposedly planning to implement.
And it doesn't take a genius to figure out that a flirtation with Martz, and his agent Bob LaMonte, could turn sour. Quickly.
Here's our advice, Lions. Interview your candidates quietly. Settle on a top candidate without fanfare. Work on the contract discreetly. And then announce the hire.
Until then, shut the hell up about it.
POSTED 9:01 a.m. EST; LAST UPDATED 10:02 a.m. EST, February 3, 2006
UPSHAW TRIES TO ONE-UP TAGS
NFLPA executive director Gene Upshaw says that he plans to recommend in March decertification of the union that he runs, in order to block the possibility of a lockout by owners. Put simply, if there's no union in place, the owners can't tell the players not to show up for work.
Per The Washington Post, decertification would be a precursor to an antitrust action by the players if/when the owners collectively impose a new system of player compensation and free agency after expiration of the current CBA.
Article VLII, Section 3 of the Collective Bargaining Agreement expressly contemplates decertification of the union, and the antitrust lawsuit that likely would follow. In that provision, the NFL and its member Clubs have waived "any rights they may have to assert any antitrust labor exemption defense based upon any claim that the termination by the NFLPA of its status as a collective bargaining representative is or would be a sham, pretext, ineffective, requires additional steps, or has no in fact occurred."
So let's be clear on this -- decertification would not occur until after the current CBA expires in 2008. Thus, it's not a maneuver that will have any impact on the next two NFL seasons.
Then why is Upshaw talking about it now, you ask?
Here's our theory. We think that the NFL and the NFLPA are getting close to working out a deal on a CBA extension, and that Upshaw's carefully-timed comments, which come only one day before Commissioner Paul Tagliabue's "State of the League" address, were intended to give the union some leverage as they hammer out any and all remaining key terms in the negotiations.
After all, the outcome of the current CBA discussions will be Tagliabue's ultimate legacy as Commissioner. He needs to get a deal done, and he knows it. When peppered with questions on Friday regarding Upshaw's rhetoric and the status of the discussions, look for Tags to make broad, general statements reflecting confidence and optimism that an agreement will be reached.
Then, look for such an agreement to be announced a week or two before the start of free agency.
Again, we're just speculating here. Since neither the NFL clubs nor the union are talking about the status of the efforts to extend the CBA, it's virtually impossible to know what's really happening. But based on the plain language of the CBA, we doubt that Upshaw spoke out on Thursday in order to tell the NFL something it didn't already know. Instead, we think Upshaw is trying to control part of the agenda for Tags' annual visit with the media, in the hopes that the Commish will essentially guarantee ongoing labor peace in response to the questions regarding decertification that he's now certain to face. TAZ DINGS HIS ANKLE (OR DOES HE?) So much for the Tasmanian Devil returning kicks on Sunday. Steelers safety Troy Polamalu injured his ankle on Thursday, and is listed as probable for the Super Bowl. With a bum ankle, the possibility of Polamalu getting the ball in his hands in any way other than an interception or fumble recovery is likely minimal. Still, it's important to remember what the term "probable" really means. Even though guys with much more experience and intelligence than us (or is it we?) continue to write that the "probable" designation means that there's a 75 percent chance the guy will play, the real meaning of the term (as we 'splained on October 10), is that there is a "[v]irtual certainty that player will be available for normal duty." So now we're starting to wonder whether Troy's injury designation is a Trojan horse of sorts. If there's buzz that Polamalu might make an appearance on offense or special teams, what better way to kill it than to declare that Taz has a bad ankle? Then again, teams never manipulate the injury report. BRADY PLAYED WITH HERNIA On that same topic, it turns out that Pats quarterback Tom Brady has a sports hernia. According to The Boston Herald, he played roughly half of the season with the injury. And that the Pats never listed him on the injury report as having a hernia or a groin injury. This is where the accurate definition of "probable" cuts against a team that might otherwise hope to conceal a guy's injury. Since the term means that there is a "virtual certainty" that the player will be available for normal duty, common sense suggests that even a minor injury that still leaves the guy "virtually certain" to play should appear on the list. But these are the Pats, whom some regard as the masters of manipulation of the injury report. Listing Brady as having a hernia or a groin injury would have sparked a continuous firestorm in the media (see McNabb, Donovan) -- and it also would have been the equivalent of painting a bull's-eye on Brady's crotch. And it wasn't a minor condition. Per the report, other players on the team were aware that he was hobbled. "I didn't know how severe it was," linebacker Willie McGinest said, "but I knew it was bothering him. But you have guys who play with all types of injuries across the league and on our team. Being the kind of competitor he is, he wasn’t going to let it slow him down." BOWLEN THROWS WATER ON T.O. TALK Four days after a surprise visit by receiver Terrell Owens to the Denver Broncos, owner Pat Bowlen tried to put the trip in perspective. "This is a process, and when a player like this becomes available, we just felt like we owed it to ourselves to let him know that at the appropriate time, we might be interested," Bowlen said Thursday, according to The Denver Post. "We're not going to be the only team he visits. The only reason why I think this story created such an uproar was because we were the first ones he talked to. "Obviously, there is concern about character. That is why we wanted to talk to him and why we talked to many of our own players. We don't take the character element with a player lightly. If he doesn't conform to the way we do things with the Denver Broncos, then he won't be playing for the Denver Broncos. It's as simple as that." Okay, we read that last paragraph seven times and we still laugh when we see the words "[w]e don't take the character element with a player lightly." Hello? Dale Carter? Daryl Gardener? Maurice Clarett? We'd hate to see what kind of a team they'd have if they did take character lightly. Apart from all of that, we think that Bowlen is trying to give Coach Kevlar an easy out if/when the team doesn't follow through on T.O. Indeed, we've heard from several sources that Bowlen has no intention to add Owens to the team. So if Owens ends up in Denver, it's further proof that Mike Shanahan has far more influence and power in the organization than should anyone who doesn't, you know, own the thing. POSTED 9:55 p.m. EST, February 2, 2006
MARTZ BACKS OUT OF LIONS GIG
Our computer, in the end, is safe.
We'd recently told a reader that we'd consume the damn thing if Mike Martz stooped to accept a job as an offensive coordinator in 2006. On Wednesday night, it was looking like it would be time to start chewing on the motherboard.
But now Martz is out.
The issue reportedly came down to money. Martz wanted a three-year deal worth just under $1.5 million a year, per ESPN's Chris Mortensen. The Lions wouldn't do it.
"Obviously, I took the job," Martz told The Associated Press "It just didn't work out with the money."
More evidence, in our view, that the Lions know not what they do. Martz's requested salary isn't out of line in light of his skills, experiences, and the market. The Redskins are paying Al Saunders $2 million per year on a three-year deal -- and Martz is more accomplished that Saunders.
It'd be interesting to know how close the two sides got to reaching a deal, and whether in the end the impasse was more about the egos of Matt Millen and/or agent Bob LaMonte than about the gap between the parties' respective positions.
We also wonder whether Martz would have even worked out on head coach Rod Marinelli's staff. Marinelli was hired to be a disciplinarian and play smash-mouth football. So Martz, the king of the finesse attack, was gonna run the offense?
The whole escapade is further proof that the organization is a mess. They picked a guy who didn't fit with the new approach, and then they weren't willing to pay what it took to get the guy they wanted.
Meanwhile, Marinelli says that he has yet to speak with quarterback Joey Harrington, and that he doesn't plan to do so until a new coordinator is hired. What the hell is that all about? Does Rod first need to know whether his new coordinator wants Harrington so that the head coach can decide whether to suck up to Joey or whether to brush him off?
It's stupid. It's asinine. And it bolsters, in our opinion, the talk in some circles that Marinelli will be the NFL's latest Les Steckel by the time it's all said and done.
POSTED 9:00 p.m. EST; UPDATED 9:17 p.m. EST, February 2, 2006
MICHAELS SOON TO BE OUT
We're hearing strong and stronger indications that Al Michaels will be released from his contract with ESPN for 2006 and beyond, and that he'll instead join current broadcast partner John Madden on Sunday nights at NBC.
As widely speculated, we're told that ESPN will instead go with a trio of Mike Tirico on play-by-play, and Joe Theismann and Tony Kornheiser providing the color commentary.
So, basically, Michaels pulled a T.O. The veteran broadcaster signed a contract and then later decided not to honor it.
BERNSTEIN OUT AT CBS?
There's rampant talk in industry circles that CBS sideline reporter Bonnie Bernstein will leave the network after the Super Bowl.
She's scheduled to work the sideline for the CBS/Westwood One Radio broadcast of the game, but then she's likely to depart. Word is that she's grown unhappy at CBS, and that she wants to pursue an anchor type of position, possibly not in sports.
Bernstein also has launched a consulting company, Velvet Hammer Media, which offers aspiring broadcasters a phone consultation with Ms. Bernstein for the reasonable price (if the quoted numbers were yen) of $1,250. A follow up will only (only?) set you back another $950.
But there's a bargain -- a package of three follow ups costs a mere $2,150.
So you can get four phone four calls with Ms. Bernstein for the grand total of $3,400.
Bernstein's web site doesn't say anything about the duration of the calls. For that kind of money, however, they'd better be 10 hours long or involve a lot of four-letter words.
POSTED 8:48 p.m. EST, February 2, 2006
TAZ SHOULD RETURN KICKS
Earlier on Thursday, we posted a story explaining that, if the Steelers find themselves in a close game in the second half on Super Sunday, safety Troy Polamalu should be inserted into the kick return team given his tremendous abilities with the ball in his hands.
When preparing to update the site on Thursday night, we screwed up while attempting to load the live version of the page onto the official PFT computer.
We're not smart enough to remember what we said this morning, and we're too lazy to re-write it from scratch.
Bottom line -- we think that it would be a great move to put the ball into the hands of the most thrilling broken field runners we've ever seen. Several readers e-mailed throughout the day reminding us what happened to Jason Shoehorn when he tried to return kickoffs, but his ACL tear happened in a meaningless preseason game. The potential reward is much greater in this case, if the Tasmanian Devil is unleashed with an NFL title in the balance.
POSTED 8:18 a.m. EST, February 2, 2006
WATERS GETS NO SIGNING BREAD
A league source has shared with us the details regarding the contract extension recently signed by Chiefs guard Brian Waters.
The strangest thing about the deal is that is carries no signing bonus.
Instead, Waters will get a $4 million roster bonus on the fifth day of the 2006 league year, and a $12,500 roster bonus for each 2006 game in which he is on the active roster. He's also eligible for a $100,000 workout bonus, which he'll receive only if he participates in all OTA's and mandatory minicamps.
In 2007, Waters is eligible for a $3 million roster bonus on the fifth day of the league year, which is fully guaranteed for injury. He'll also get a $31,250 roster bonus for each game in which he is on the active roster, and a $200,000 workout bonus subject to the same terms as above.
In 2008, Waters is eligible for a $2.5 million roster bonus on the fifth day of the league year, with a 100 percent injury guarantee, and the same per-game roster bonus and workout bonus terms as in 2007.
In 2009 through 2011, he gets the same per-game roster bonus and offseason workout bonus.
So the only truly guaranteed money in the deal is the $4 million 2006 roster bonus and his $545,000 salary, if he's on the roster when the season opens. And the Chiefs will realize no cap hit by releasing or trading him, assuming that the salary cap survives beyond the coming season. Sure, there's another $5.5 million in future roster boni that are fully guaranteed in the event of injury, but if new coach Herm Edwards a/k/a Jackie Chiles simply decides that Waters has lost his mojo, Waters gets no money beyond the initial $4 million.
Look for more deals like this one to be signed in 2006, since signing bonus money can be prorated only over four years, due to the status of the CBA. The losers generally in this regard will be the players, who'll have more of their money tied up in future years, with less of the cash in their pockets when they sign.
SPLIT OPINIONS ON LEINART
Since mentioning in this here space several days back whispers of a possible draft slide by USC quarterback Matt Leinart, we've heard all sorts of different opinions from all sources of league insiders.
Some think he might slip on draft day. Some think he won't.
Said one league insider: "The agent thing is part of the problem because it shed light on what this guy is all about. He's not about football. He's about Hollywood and being L.A. People really worried about it last year when he was on the 'People Magazine circuit,' clubbing with people in that lifestyle. He would have slipped last year too, trust me."
Said another: "If I had the first choice in the draft it would be Leinart. I have studied him for three years and he is the best and most prepared QB to come in the league in years. "He is not the athlete that Palmer is but he is a much better quarterback and leader. He is for more advanced than [Eli] Manning. People want to take him apart yet all he has done is win 33 games in a row and lose only two games in three years. He has brought his team back from behind on numerous occasions. In 2004 he had four new offensive linemen and all his receivers were new, mostly freshmen and sophomores, yet they still went undefeated and won the National Championship. What else does a guy have to do? "In my opinion the people who take shots are the ones that want him to fall to them. There is no way he gets past Tennessee." Said yet another: "He might slide but people would be foolish to let him slide. The kid's got great poise and instincts. By the time you develop Vince Young and Jay Cutler, Leinart will have already taken another team to the playoffs. He's just a lot more advanced mentally and technique-wise. He may not have the raw upside of the other two but we've seen in our league that you don’t have to have a howitzer -- Brees, Manning, Brady, Hasselbeck -- to be good."
So, at this point, who knows? The debate will continue through draft day, and likely beyond.
And Leinart isn't the only one who is in danger of some slippage in late April. There's also talk that Texas quarterback Vince Young might fall, now that the euphoria of his Rose Bowl performance has subsided.
But, hey -- maybe it's good to be the third quarterback off the board. Just ask Ben Roethlisberger.
WHERE'S McNAIR'S LEVERAGE?
In response to recent proclamations from agent Bus Cook that Titans quarterback Steve McNair won't take a reduction in his $10 million salary for 2006, some league insiders are scratching their heads.
A guy's value to his team is driven in large part by what he'll otherwise get on the open market. If McNair were available via free agency, he'd never get $10 million in salary to join, say, the Dolphins or the Cardinals.
So how does he merit that much from the Titans?
The other thing that Cook and McNair need to keep in mind is McNair's prospects beyond the completion of his football career. If he finishes his career in Tennessee, he likely can continue to annually earn six figures indefinitely via endorsements and other non-work work. If he bolts and plays a couple of years or more somewhere else, that Nashville goodwill could evaporate.
The problem, of course, is that Cook
has been emboldened by the Titans' apparent willingness to pay more
to McNair that the market would dictate. And that's very
odd, in our opinion, since the Titans have shown in the past that
they're not afraid of running guys out of town. POSTED 11:29 p.m. EST, February 1, 2006
MIKE ALREADY BEING A MEATHEAD
According to the guys at KFFL.com, new Jaguars assistant head coach Mike Tice told Jacksonville radio station WOKV on Wednesday that he already has spoken with one of the Minnesota Vikings' 16 free agents regarding the possibility of joining the Jags for 2006. Tice declined to name the player.
The problem is that, until free agency opens, these players remain the property of the Minnesota Vikings. Thus, Tice has admitted to a tampering violation.
The development should surprise no one. Tice reluctantly conceded a year ago to the scalping of Super Bowl tickets, in blatant violation of league rules. The Commissioner imposed a $100,00 fine against Tice for the transgression.
This time around, the Vikings likely will be required to file tampering charges before the Commish can act. And we wonder whether the NFL will "stack" dissimilar offenses when disciplining guys who can't seem to stay on the right side of obvious rules.
It'll be interesting to see what happens next.
POSTED 9:35 p.m. EST, February 1, 2006
'SKINS SAY NO GO ON T.O.
In the wake of reports suggesting that the Washington Redskins are now the favorites to land receiver Terrell Owens, we decided to go straight to the source and ask whether the reports are accurate.
Redskins Senior Vice President Karl Swanson told us that it's not going to happen. "We think Terrell is an exceptional talent, however, we do not see him as a fit with the Redskins," Swanson said Wednesday night.
There have you it, folks. An official statement that the Redskins are not -- and will not be -- in the mix for Owens.
This development, if acknowledged by the media generally, could throw a bucket of cold water on the smoldering stew of rumors suddenly linking Owens to multiple suitors.
With that said, someone is sure to sign him. The only question is how much he'll get paid, and whether the Eagles will get anything in trade.
YOU LIKE US. . . .
Or you hate us. Either way, you're reading us. January 2006 was our biggest month ever, with more than 2 million page views and a whopping 261,000 unique visitors -- a 30 percent increase over our prior high water mark.
So thanks for liking us. Or for hating us. Just keep reading us.
And tell your friends. And your enemies. And anyone who's willing to listen. Or who isn't.
POSTED 7:23 p.m. EST; UPDATED 7:46 p.m. EST, February 1, 2006
T.O. TO D.C.?
Feel free to check our archives -- it's in there. Several months ago, we predicted that Eagles receiver Terrell Owens ultimately would land with the Redskins.
Now, Peter King will report on Wednesday night (as reported by Adam Schefter) that the 'Skins are the favorites to acquire Owens.
Both on-the-record and off-the-record, Redskins personnel have long denied any interest in Owens. But that only has made us more convinced that the 'Skins are and have been in play for the Pro Bowler.
And although there never will be any firm proof of tampering (see Milloy, Lawyer), we believe that the seeds for the ultimate transaction were planted not long after Drew Rosenhaus became Owens' new agent. Rosenhaus represents several key Redskins players (Clinton Portis, Santana Moss, Sean Taylor), and he has a great relationship with the organization. How far-fetched is it to conclude that Rosenhaus and owner Dan Snyder (or someone acting on Snyder's behalf) had a conversation that (wink, nod) never really happened regarding the terms that the 'Skins hypothetically would be willing to offer to a high-end pass-catcher in 2006?
Think about it -- which team benefited the most from the fact that T.O. went turdy and ruined the Eagles' season in 2005? But for the Philly implosion (which very well might have happened anyway due to quarterback Donovan McNabb's sports hernia), the Redskins would not have made it to the playoffs.
Now, the 'Skins can push themselves over the top in the division and the conference by adding a bona fide playmaker in Owens.
The only glitch, in our view, is that the emerging market for T.O.'s services could enable the Eagles to trade him. So would Philly do a deal with a division rival?
Of course, Owens can essentially block any trade by refusing to agree to terms of compensation that would permit the Eagles to sign him to a new deal and then trade him. If Owens already has his sights set on D.C., he merely needs to refuse to agree to a contract that would enable the Eagles to ship him elsewhere.
And although the growing interest in Owens might prompt a team like the Broncos eventually to swing a trade with the Eagles under the terms of his current contract, which require $7.5 million in cash payments by March 15, no team is going to absorb such an obligation unless T.O. is willing to go happily.
In that regard, keep this in mind -- Rosenhaus doesn't earn a nickel from his representation of Owens until his existing deal is replaced with a new contract.
Not long ago, it looked like the market for Owens might be on the light side. Now, it looks like T.O. will find a new home -- and that he could replace much of the money that he would have made under the contract with the Eagles that he deemed insufficient.
MANGINI WHIFFING ON ASSISTANTS?
We're hearing that new Jets coach Eric Mangini is having trouble putting together a staff of assistants. He's been rebuffed, we're told, a "bunch of times" in his efforts to get the guys he has wanted.
There's no clear reason for his problems in this regard. It could be due to his age.
It also could be due to the perception that the team's front office is in a state of flux. Many league insiders believe that G.M. Terry Bradway is on his way out as G.M., and that the job eventually will go to assistant G.M. Mike Tannenbaum.
Some believe that Bradway hung himself by spending most of his time working out of his home. In contrast, Tannenbaum has been a regular presence in the office, allowing him to solidify his relationship with the owner.
The only problem is that, if cap-and-contracts guy Tannenbaum ends up as the G.M., there won't be an established personnel guy running the show.
This opens the door, of course, for Mangini to have even greater influence when it comes to the configuration of the roster. Of course, such a development could attract assistant coaches to town.
Our guess is that the general goofiness surrounding the franchise over the past month has contributed significantly to Mangini's inability to put together a group of assistants that will help him to achieve success sooner rather than later.
BIG BEN BAGS ANOTHER MILLION
Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger picked up some extra money to finance any future games of quarter bounce on Wednesday. According to Darren Rovell of ESPN.com, Roethlisberger has signed a one-year exclusive autograph deal worth $1 million with Mounted Memories (the name of the company might also describe the recollections of the women with whom Big Ben was cavorting in those widely-circulated photos).
Mounted Memories is owned by Dreams, Inc., a publicly-traded company.
"He's not prohibited from casually signing for fans," said agent Ryan Tollner. "But he's obviously not going to sign the same piece over and over again for a guy he thinks is bringing it to eBay."
Big Ben's exploits with B-level broads and a bottle of booze apparently had no effect on his ability to land the $1 million payday. Then again, maybe Ben put his John Hancockberger on the paperwork after he caught wind of the portfolio of arguably unflattering pics -- and before the folks at Mounted Memories knew of them.
POSTED 8:30 a.m. EST; LAST UPDATED 11:17 a..m. EST, February 1, 2006
MEATHEAD FINDS WORK
Our favorite (but not in a good way) NFL coach, Mike Tice, won't be sitting at home in 2006, after all. Tice, to whom we lovingly refer as "Meathead," has joined the staff of Jack Del Rio in Jacksonville as assistant head coach/offense.
Tice's contract wasn't renewed with the Vikings after the 2005 season, and for good reason. In four full years, his teams underachieved their way to one playoff appearance. Sure, there was a "lookie what we found" postseason win in Green Bay in January 2005, but a week later the team showed its true colors in being crushed by the Eagles.
The team's relative success in 2004 prompted then-owner Red McCombs to pick up a $1 million option on Tice, extending his deal through 2005. The move also made it a little easier for McCombs to sell the team at a tidy profit of more than $300 million, since the new owner wasn't stuck with a coach with multiple years remaining on his contract.
But after Tice learned that he'd still be the team's coach in 2005, the bottom fell out. He was whiplashed with evidence that he'd been scalping Super Bowl tickets -- allegations that he initially denied and then later admitted. He coughed up a $100,000 fine for his transgression.
Then came the football season, and the weight of grossly unrealistic expectations for a team that had traded away one of the best players in the game, Randy Moss. A poor start was compounded by the Love Boat fiasco, and not even a six-game winning streak was enough to make new owner Zygi Wilf give Tice serious consideration for a new deal.
In Jacksonville, Tice joins another coach with a history of not-so-bright moves. A few years back, Del Rio was a Del Dumbass when he brought a hunk of wood and an ax into the locker room as a prop for his "keep choppin' wood" mantra.
Punter Chris Hanson obliged -- and nearly chopped of his leg.
Still, the perception is that the tide is rising in the 'Ville. The team came off of a 12-4 regular season and its first playoff appearance under Del Rio. Tice can play a valuable role in the ongoing improvement of the offense, especially because he is adept at spotting and developing raw talent along the offensive line.
And if Del Rio can't take the team to the next level in 2006, the Meathead could end up being an enticing option for a front office that might prefer a big lummox who'll not expect big money -- and who'll pay proper homage to Paul Vance and otherwise know where he fits in the greater scheme of things (see Mike McCarthy, Scott Linehan, Sean Payton).
HUE HAD BEEN BABYSITTING HENRY
Based on a tip from a reader, we've confirmed via a league source that Bengals receiver Chris Henry had been living with receivers coach Hue Jackson after Henry's December 2005 arrest on charges of marijuana possession.
Apparently, some relatives and/or friends of Henry either moved in with or near Henry in Kentucky after Hurricane Katrina struck his home state of Louisiana. Some of these folks apparently weren't the best of influences on him, so after Henry was busted during his rookie season he started bunking with Jackson.
But Jackson could only watch Henry so closely after the season ended. Based on published reports regarding Henry's most recent arrest, he was spending more time that he should have in Orlando.
Kudos to the Bengals for realizing that Henry needed a full-time babysitter, but shame on the Bengals for not having a better plan to keep him out of trouble before he was set loose on the free world.
Henry slipped to round three of the April 2005 draft due in large part to questions regarding his character. Some teams even struck him from their draft boards.
And as one league insider told us on Tuesday, "I told you so."
IMG SUES FORMER AGENT
The Cleveland Plain Dealer reports that megafirm IMG has filed a motion for a temporary restraining order against former employee Bill Henkel, accusing him of trying to pilfer clients.
The action has been filed in the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, and IMG claims that Henkel violated a non-solicitation agreement in his contract by soliciting IMG clients.
Per the report, the lawsuit is supported by an affidavit signed by Chargers running back LaDainian Tomlinson, an IMG client. Presumably, Tomlinson has testified via his affidavit that Henkel tried to entice him to join Henkel's new shop.
In a 2004 article regarding the Manning brothers that still appears on the IMG official web site, Henkel is identified as the firm's director of athlete marketing.
Typically, a temporary restraining order is considered on an ex parte basis, which means that the party seeking to restrain the other party asks for the Court, without the involvement of the other party, to freeze the status quo until a hearing can be conducted on a motion for a preliminary injunction. Through a motion for preliminary injunction, IMG would then ask the Court to prevent Henkel from soliciting any IMG clients until the parties' rights can be fully and finally considered and determined.
In order to obtain relief prior to the issuance of a final ruling in a party's favor, the party typically must establish several factors, including a likelihood of eventual success in the litigation and a threat of harm that cannot be compensated or cured by an award of monetary damages.
IMG also has recourse against Henkel before the NFLPA, which can discipline agents who attempt to lure players already under contract with other agents.
BIG BEN LIKES THE BOOZE
We received from several readers on Tuesday photos of Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger getting his Bobby Layne on with a group of female fans.
Though the pics are undated, Big Ben is sporting the same beard that he has worn for much of the back end of the season, so our guess is that the photos are of relatively recent vintage.
We don't know what to make of this, other than it tends to confirm our suspicion that Big Ben might not be the brightest bulb in the box. It's one thing for a young guy to kill some random brain cells -- it's another thing to brazenly pose for photos that inevitably will end up on the Internet.
Then again, virtually everyone has a digital camera nowadays, and our guess is that Ben had belted back a few before he decided to start saying "cheese."
Regardless, the guy's playing great football and we doubt that this will have any impact on his performance in the Super Bowl. Though he's matured in a lot of ways since 2004 (and far faster than we ever thought he would), he's still a kid who's entitled to go out and have a good time. As long as he doesn't, you know, point a gun at anyone while wearing his Steelers jersey, he should be okay.
WEDNESDAY MORNING ONE-LINERS
King Carl says that the Chiefs are "somewhat interested" in receiver Terrell Owens (translation -- Peterson is willing to enter the bidding in order to force the Broncos to pay too much for him).
The NFL is coughing up $20 million for the efforts to get the Superdome ready for some football.
Steelers RB Duce Staley is absent from Detroit due to the passing of his fahter.
From the "Things that Make You Go 'Doh!'" file, Pats LB Chad Brown, who has played for the Steelers and Seahawks, took less money to sign with New England a year ago than the Steelers were offering because he wanted the best chance to get to the Super Bowl.
The Aggies continue to squeeze the baggies of the Seahawks.
Eugene Robinson probably wishes that Super Bowl XXXIII had been in Detroit.
Offensive line guru Alex Gibbs is staying with the Falcons, despite feelers from new Texans coach Gary Kubiak.
Mike Martz is close to accepting a one-year, $2 million contract to become the Lions offensive coordinator (if we were he -- but he we not be -- we'd officially sign on as a "consultant" in order to be free to interview for and accept a head coaching job elsewhere if the Lions are in the playoffs).
Chiefs G Brian Waters has signed a six-year extension.
The Pittsburgh-area teacher accused of humiliating a student who wore a Broncos jersey to class won't be disciplined (they're instead giving the guy the key to the city and a case of pierogies).
The D.C. media is figuring out that Steelers WR Antwaan Randle El would be a good complement to Santana Moss.
Seahawks QB Matt Hasselbeck told OL Robbie Tobeck not to worry after Tobeck suffered an injury in training camp because "hobbits heal faster than humans."
Bengals WR Chad Johson, who previously guaranteed that his team would beat the Colts and ascend to Super Bowl XL, has now guaranteed that Cincy will make it to Super Bowl XLI (hey, if he makes that guarantee every year, he'll eventually get it right).
Looking for more? Click here for the rumor mill archives.
|
|
||||||
|
|
|||||||||
|
|
|||||||||
|
|
|||||||||
|
|
|||||||||
|
|
|||||||||
|
|
|||||||||
|
|
|||||||||
|
|
|||||||||
|
|
|
||||||||
|
©2005 Football Talk, LLC. All
Rights Reserved. Site designed by xny
developments and hosted by
Citynet, LLC. |
|
||||||||
|
|
|||||||||